Dating ex gf sister

I remember being absolutely livid when my ex left me to date my roommate, who was the little sister of one of my best friends and like a sister to me. I can't.
Table of contents

So yeah, I think someone should sit the 21 year old down and make sure she understands what the 31 year old doesn't seem to be able to. With him I think someone should give him a ruder awakening for the obtusity shown, might as well be from someone this directly affects and who has the girls' best interests at heart.

It's not a parent's job to prevent their children, especially their adult children, from making mistakes. It's the parent's job to ensure that a mistake doesn't crush their life and they're able to recover from making one. This is true no matter what your age is. At 50 it is certainly better to have a healthy relationship with your parents and have them looking out for you, provided they're still alive of course.

That's certainly your prerogative, and if you feel confident that one internet post and a few comments in response are enough to base that kind of decision on, more power to you.

Want to add to the discussion?

I for one do not share your sentiment and wouldn't give that same advice based on the same information provided. I think someone should sit the 21 year old down and make sure she understands what the 31 year old doesn't seem to be able to.

You're making an awful lot of judgements based on a limited amount of information. Obviously OP was 'acceptable enough' to have dated one member of the family for an unusually long time based on today's standards , so it's difficult to justify judging them negatively as a person. If OP was dating the best friend instead of the sister, would you still advise the girl to run?

People Who Married Or Dated Their Ex's Sibling Reveal How It Turned Out

If not, why not? If I were the Father in this situation I would sit my youngest down and have an adult conversation with her. Without judging or demanding anything I would lead her down the path of enlightenment that allowed her to discover on her own some of the pitfalls and potential negatives associated with the relationship moving forward that she may not have been able to come to on her own, but I would never be so foolish as to think that my opinion on the relationship mattered at all If she's happy that's all that matters.

As far as he goes, I'd never say a word to him about it, because doing so crosses so many boundaries I can't even begin to list them all, and for you to say that as a parent I should kick his ass says a lot about your level of maturity. Assault is a criminal act and you really just suggested that an adult commit a crime of violence against another adult because their adult child fucked their adult sister's adult ex-boyfriend.

If violence is your tool of first resort, you're going to have a bad time at this game called life. Do you have a hard on from the wall of text you just wrote? You should masturbate and recite it back to yourself as you cum. If you care about this girl, I think you should seriously consider the effect this might have on her relationship with her family. Would this ruin her relationship with her sister? What about her parents?


  • Dating your ex's sister: Is it ever a good idea? | SoSuave Discussion Forum?
  • meeting dating websites!
  • Do you think GAG should combine these topics?.
  • Welcome to Reddit,.
  • How This "Nice Guy" Steals Women from Jerks.
  • dating bradenton florida!
  • I'm dating my ex's little sister. : confession?

Is that really something you want for her? Many twenty-one years olds still don't have the life experience to really grasp the impact this sort of thing can have for a lifetime. You sound like you're old enough that you should have a bit of perspective on the matter.

People Who Married Or Dated Their Ex's Sibling Reveal How It Turned Out | HuffPost UK

Twelve years is a long time. What are the chances her sister would be able to accept you in the new role you're putting yourself in. If you don't care what she thinks in the capacity of an ex that cheated on you, that's fine and good, but what about her in the capacity of a sister to the girl you're sleeping with? This is a bad arrangement with virtually no chance of a happy ending long-term and you know it. You might not feel like you've done anything wrong that you need to regret thus far, but if you drag this out to get to the point where this doesn't work out, the truth is out, and this girl becomes estranged from her family, you'd have to be pretty inconsiderate not to feel any responsibility.

This is a time bomb just waiting to go off in your face.

I’M DATING MY EX-GIRLFRIEND’S SISTER! *BACKFIRES*

The amount of drama you're walking into simply because your penis is dictating your moves in life.. I think you're really underestimating the ramifications of this move, especially if you're both thinking long term. Think of the Xmas parties, Thanksgiving Dinners, Birthdays, etc that you'll have to sit through with their family and you have that dark cloud over your head. Do you, and all that. But I really think you're sailing the ship a little too close to the iceberg.

Yeah, I'm scared about that. Her father and I actually had a really good relationship before. What if he thinks I'm just some asshole who's fucking around with his daughters? I don't think that he'd assume that but He has told me before that he thinks that I'm a good man and that I'm good for his daughter. I'm not sure what his reaction would be. I'm not looking for a career woman so that's not really a problem. I have plenty of money, I am mostly looking for someone who can have my kids and be a homemaker. You know, someone that is there after I come home from a long day's work.

She wants kids and she's not all that career driven. We haven't talked about it at length because we've only just started dating but I have told her that is what I'm looking for and she said that is what she wants as well. Also, women peak physically in their late teens-early twenties IMO. When I'm 40, she'll be That's not really that big of a difference. At that point I'll have more money and probably be much more successful so it's not like I'll be some fat old man, I'll still be successful and attractive.

He said you were good for his 30 year old daughter that you had a 12 year relationship with, not his young daughter that you have known since she was 6. This is going to end messy and the whole taboo of it is probably really attractive to her. Her family will likely to be pretty disgusted by it and probably pretty pissed. I wouldn't go out of my way to make the relationship public until you both know it's a long term thing, and then brace yourself for some backlash. At most, remember that she's She has so much growing to do. In a few years she probably won't even be close to the same person, I think your early 20's really shape who you become and when you grow into your adult life.

There is no such thing as a mature adult 21 year old, despite what "mature" 21 year olds think of themselves. It's just a huge development area in your life. You know, there was actually an On user suggested to try to alter time and make bad things not happen and to increase the speed of development in some areas. Even if he'd be the Lord and savior himself nobody would listen to him.

Most Helpful Girl

Because he's "just 5, he could never be that". But ohhh boy, 13 years later he's suddenly really Jesus but, its too late. I've always been kinda "ahead of time". If I'm not riddled by hormones I usually have a pretty "mature way" of thinking. But hey, I'm only 18, I could never be mature, or reliable, or anything associated with being mature, because I'm only I've never met someone your age that was mature, mature for the age yes, mature?

You may disagree with me now but that's typical for 18 year olds. Yeah, you're not alone in your way of thinking. I never said you couldn't be reliable. Or that you are not mature for your age. But there is a growth that happens during this period of your life. At least for most people. Ask anyone in their 30's if they're the same person they were when they were This time in your life is for figuring your shit out.

Making your own opinions, gaining experiences by interacting with the real world in an adult way.

Can I date my ex girlfriend's sister?

Surviving on your own without anyone else's legs to stand on. Now I'm not saying this is a one size fits all. But I can tell you that most young adults think that they are mature, that they have their shit together, they don't, but it's part of the process. A 21 year old engaging in a hidden sexual relationship with her sisters ex of 12 years does not scream maturity.

It's a really bad way to go about it honestly, selfish and potentially hurtful and divisive. My high school girlfriend was the same way, and around age or so that ALL changed. There was an established plan and all that. Out of nowhere it changed and our relationship ended. I'm just saying that people change their goals and really start evaluating what they want out of life, so I wouldn't count on it staying consistent given her age.

I myself am now in a substantially better relationship with a woman 15 years older than me. We've been together almost 10 years now, so it's not like the age difference can't work. That's my problem with the age difference. Not that its 10 years, but that 21yo will not be the same person at 25, whether or not she's in a relationship with this Weirdo sorry not sorry, but im 27 and my baby sis just turned 20 yesterday.

'It’s definitely weird because I see my ex sometimes at events.'

If my ex who's 30 would try anything like this I'd probably skin him. She's still got a lot to discover about herself. Do you see her as your equal? Because the way you describe this relationship seems extremely one-way to me.. What about her choices, her dreams? Maybe she'd like to discover a bit of the world before being a mother?